The Health Insurance Risk-Sharing Plan (HIRSP) provides medical and
prescription drug insurance for individuals who cannot obtain coverage
in the private market because of the severity of their health conditions. In
the late 1990s, it was also designated as Wisconsin’s plan to meet federal
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) regulations
and to provide health insurance to people who lose employer-sponsored
group health insurance and meet other specified criteria.
Program costs are shared by policyholders, health insurance companies
that do business in Wisconsin, and health care providers. During fiscal
year (FY) 2005-06, HIRSP also received $2.5 million in federal funds
designated for high-risk health insurance pools.
HIRSP offers eligible applicants three plans:
The primary plan, plan 1A, is similar to coverage provided by many
private major medical health insurance plans.
The alternative plan, plan 1B, offers the same coverage as plan 1A
but at lower premium rates, because policyholders pay a higher
deductible before HIRSP begins paying claims.
An additional plan, plan 2, is available to Wisconsin residents under
the age of 65 who participate in the federal Medicare program
because of a disability.
At the request of the Department of Health and Family Services (DHFS),
we completed a financial audit of HIRSP. Our audit report contains our
unqualified opinion on HIRSP’s financial statements and related notes as
of and for the fiscal years ending June 30, 2006 and 2005.
Financial Status
At the end of FY 2000-01, HIRSP
reported a significant accounting
deficit, with unrestricted assets
of ($8.2 million).
After implementing an accrualbased
funding approach, HIRSP’s
financial position improved significantly. At the end of FY 2005-06, it
reported an unrestricted net asset
balance of $3.9 million.
A balance of excess policyholder
premiums increased by $10.0 million
during FY 2005-06 and reached
$19.5 million as of June 30, 2006.
At the direction of HIRSP’s governing
board, $13.3 million of that
amount was applied toward the
policyholders’ share of costs, which
has helped to limit subsequent
premium increases.
The excess premium balance
accumulated over the past several
years, because the statutory floor for
premium rates has typically been
greater than premiums needed to
fund the policyholders’ share
60 percentof HIRSP’s costs.
Statutory changes implemented as
part of 2005 Wisconsin Act 74
removed the statutory premium
floor effective July 1, 2006.
Enrollment and Claims Costs
Increasing HIRSP enrollments and
increasing claims costs have presented
management and funding
challenges for several years.
However, more recent trends
suggest that enrollment and costs
are beginning to moderate.
HIRSP enrollment decreased
3.8 percent during FY 2005-06 and
5.6 percent during FY 2006-07, to
reach 17,612 at June 30, 2007.
The most significant change in
enrollment has been in plan 2,
which is available to disabled
Wisconsin residents under the age
of 65 who participate in Medicare
and is used by many for prescription
drug coverage.
Over the last two fiscal years,
enrollment in plan 2 decreased by
44.5 percent. The decrease is largely
attributable to the requirement that,
beginning in May 2006, plan 2
policyholders must also enroll in the
federal Medicare Part D prescription
drug coverage program.
HIRSP’s net claims costs, which
represent amounts actually paid,
decreased by 1.2 percent during
FY 2005-06. In the previous four
years, net claims costs had increased
by double digits.
A major part of the FY 2005-06
decrease in net claims costs was a
$2.0 million, or 4.4 percent, decrease
in prescription drug costs. That
decrease is attributable, in part, to
plan 2 participants leaving HIRSP
as they enrolled in the Medicare
Part D program.
Costs savings were also achieved
through a change in HIRSP’s
prescription drug formulary and
increased rebates implemented
when a new pharmacy benefit
management company began
administering HIRSP in April 2005.
Finally, recent shifts in enrollment
from plan 1A to plan 1B have
contributed to more stable medical
costs during FY 2005-06. In the last
quarter of FY 2005-06, plan 1A costs
were $1,080 per member per month.
Plan 1B costs were $546 per member
month.
Program Changes
2005 Wisconsin Act 74 created the
HIRSP Authority, which assumed
responsibility for HIRSP on
July 1, 2006. The HIRSP Authority
is not a state agency and is not
subject to the State’s budgeting
process, but some level of public
accountability is retained through
open records and open meetings
requirements. The Audit Bureau
will also be required to audit HIRSP
on an annual basis.
Act 74 also made several other
significant changes to HIRSP,
including:
simplifying the complex
funding formula;
providing the HIRSP Authority
further flexibility in establishing
plan design;
tightening eligibility requirements;
and
establishing tax credits for the
insurers that help to fund HIRSP.
During its first year of operations,
the HIRSP Authority and its Board
of Directors have identified several
areas of HIRSP’s program and operations
for which they are seeking
statutory changes. The most signifi-
cant changes proposed, which
are included in 2007 Senate Bill 226/
Assembly Bill 445 and subsequent
amendments, include:
expanding the network of pharmacists
and pharmacies that can
serve HIRSP policyholders;
changing the calculation of
provider payment rates from
Medicaid-based rates to rates
established by the HIRSP
Authority Board;
expanding the subsidy programs
to all plan options for
individuals below specified
income levels;
changing the determination of
premium subsidies from a
percentage of standard-risk
rates to a discount that reduces
the unsubsidized premium rate
by a specified percentage based
on income level; and
allowing HIRSP funds to be
invested in the State Investment
Fund, which is administered
by the State of Wisconsin
Investment Board.